Climategate Doesn’t Invalidate 40 Years Of Juried Research!

Image: GlennFay36, flickr
Recently it was revealed that hundreds of emails related to global warming were hacked from the Climate Research Unit at East Anglia University in the United Kingdom. Global warming deniers claim the documents suggest that scientists are pushing an “agenda” that humans are responsible for global warming while many scientists mainain the sacandal doesn’t undermine the credibility of the scientific data. In the hundreds of emails that were stolen and have been taken out of context, there isn’t actual evidence of such a plot.
The hacked emails involve both American and European research scientists, and according to the New York Times they include “discussions of scientific data and whether it should be released, exchanges about how best to combat the arguments of skeptics, and casual comments, in some cases derisive, about specific people known for their skeptical views.”
The emails also suggest that there were “bitter feelings” involved in the debate between those on both sides of the issue of global warming and the seriousness of the threat. As we know, change is slow in any system, due to a the inherent “dynamic conservatism” in social institutions. Any veteran congressman who has seen his or her important project delayed for decades has experienced this first-had. So it doesn’t seem unlikely that climate change data would immediately be accepted by inherently skeptical scientists, some of whom have biased agendas.
One reputable group of scientists, Real Climate, has posted a response on its blog to the allegations about what information is actually contained in the hacked emails. They say: “More interesting is what is not contained in the emails. There is no evidence of any worldwide conspiracy, no mention of George Soros nefariously funding climate research, no grand plan to ‘get rid of the MWP’, no admission that global warming is a hoax, no evidence of the falsifying of data, and no ‘marching orders’ from our socialist/communist/vegetarian overlords. The truly paranoid will put this down to the hackers also being in on the plot though.”
Despite the lack of evidence of some sort of conspiracy in the scientific community, this scandal has created fodder for climate change denier groups and websites to promote their own agenda that global warming is not real. This comes at a time when international attention on the climate crisis is heightened in advance of the UN climate talks in Copenhagen in December. But let’s use some logic here.
Even though the hacked email activity raises questions about the validity of parts of the IPCC position on climate change, and the ethics of those involved, that doesn’t alter the fact that climate change data has shown high probability of anthropogenic climate change as back as far as 40 years ago! That was before the IPCC, before climate change became mainstream knowledge, before Al Gore, and before the data of climate change became a political issue.
So as the polar ice melts, sea levels rise, fresh water becomes scarce, weather becomes more unpredictable, now is not a time to be distracted by a few scientists with corporate interests and biases. Now is the time to take a leadership role on the data and do the right thing for your children and grandchildren.